Referee report by J. B. S. Haldane on 'On the Chemical basis of Morphogenesis' by A. M. Turing

View transcription
                                Referee’s Report 
To the Sectional Committee for Physiology 
Paper by A.M.Turing F.R.S.
On The Chemical basis of morphogenesis 
1. Does it contain contributions to knowledge of sufficient scientific interest for the space required? Yes 
2. Are any portions of the paper, or any illustrations, redundant? Yes 
3. Should the paper be published by the Society? Yes, subject to drastic emendations
4. If so, in the‘Philosophical Transactions’ or the‘Proceedings’? (see note on opposite page). Proceedings, if shortened. Otherwise Transactions 
5. Or could it be more appropriately published by some other body? No 
6. Is the paper suitable for reading before a meeting of the Society? Doubtful 
7. Comments or criticisms which might enable the author to improve or correct his 
statement. (Further remarks may be attached.)
I regret that my report, in the absence of figures or tables, must be 
insecurely grounded. As it is rather lengthy, I attach it. I should be glad to 
discuss the paper with the author, but may be leaving for India shortly. I have 
no objection to his being informed of my identity. In fact this might simplify 
matters especially if the author saw fit to incorporate any of my suggestions. But unfortunately I am not likely to be in England again before February.
I regard the central idea as being sufficiently important to warrant publication.
I am equally clear that the paper should not be published as it stands.
Signature J B S Haldane 
Date 28/11/51
                            
Please login to transcribe

Manuscript details

Author
Alan Turing
Reference
RR/1950-51/B62/2
Series
RR
Date
1951
IIIF
Open IIIF manifest
(What's this?)
This is a link to the IIIF web URL for this item. You can drag and drop the IIIF image link into other compatible viewers

Cite as

Referee report by J. B. S. Haldane on 'On the Chemical basis of Morphogenesis' by A. M. Turing, 1951. From The Royal Society, RR/1950-51/B62/2

Copy

Comments

Please login to comment